Your items from Chapter One carry over(not sure what happens if you don’t have a Chapter One savefile but I assume you start off with the same stuff), and they are still of use to you, from that lovely pyrite parrot (yes there are gags involving the “Mighty Pirate”) to that mysterious locket.
The game is, dare I say, easier than the first chapter,with the first half being easier, while the second part left me scratching my head sometimes(yes I did go on the fourms after a couple of hours of being stuck in a part, afterwords facepalming ). Thankfully there isn’t a “maze” sequence;in Chapter One the directions were a bit ambiguous(but admittedly not too different from Secret of Monkey Island). Oh, and no insult swordfighting; the newly introduced character mentions that its “only for farmboys now”(”Well you fight like one”). Also, she is a huge fan of Guybrush and can hold her breath for 5 minutes

My one gripe? When you get to Spinner Cay the mast repair…er…”person” can swim down to meet you basically at your boat, but it forces you to come to its store for a repair every time. The store is not a long walk from the dock but when its the fourth time you broke your mast(assuming Winston’s first hint doesn’t help) it does get a bit annoying to make that walk.

The unintentional fun? In one part you sink a ship after insulting another captain and managing to get the fired cannonball to hit the attacking captain’s ship;however, the game acts like he’s still there and allows you talk to him like his ship was still there. In addition, the door to the lower deck of his ship is left floating. There is another part involving the parrot that has a similar bug(its right before the “invisible pirate captain” BTW, you can get another pyrite turtle and hang it up on…) that is even funnier.
However, there is one bug that does detract from the experience, compression or something like that has degraded the quality of the voice acting, so there are problems with “s” sounds especially. I thought it was a problem with my integrated sound but apparently even X-Fi sound cards have this problem.
Overall a fun game for almost all ages. However if you count Halo 3/CS/GoW/CoD as your favorite games and nothing else you will be disappointed; the action is of course, a bit slow.
I strongly recommend this game to almost all(and even if you like twitch FPSes you should still try the demo) and from what I hear the Wii version isn’t too bad either, although they are a bit behind in releasing chapters for WiiWare.